Skip To Main Content

Division Edition

Regular blogs written by Upper Grades Head Tom Sellevaag.

Understanding Teen Connection: What Adolescents Need to Feel Supported

By Tom Sellevaag, Upper Grades Head

At Capitol Hill Day School, we know that meaningful relationships are foundational to learning and well-being. Across all grades, and especially in the middle school years when peer relationships become both more central and more complex, we intentionally create opportunities for students to build connections grounded in a strong sense of self. So while I’m not sure I believe that the universe drops hints in my lap to guide my daily decisions, I will say this: it was certainly fortuitous that, on the day I sat down to begin brainstorming ideas for this blog post, the Child Mind Institute’s newly-released report, Building Bridges: Teen Loneliness and Connection, landed in my inbox. The Child Mind Institute is one of my go-to resources for anything related to child and adolescent mental health—their website and their (free) digital newsletter are well worth your time—so I was eager to see what the report had to say about one of the more timely topics for those of us who love adolescents. 

The report, based on a national survey of a representative sample of 1000 teens aged 14-17, was to some extent a familiar mixture of the encouraging and the discouraging. On the plus side, sizable majorities of respondents (85-90%) reported strong connection to and support from their family, the presence of at least one peer with whom they can discuss important matters, and a belief that in-person interactions are essential to connectedness. On the other hand, half of respondents reported moderate to severe levels of loneliness, about 20% screened positive for anxiety or depression, and the increase in digital connectedness has not translated to an increase in the quality of connectedness. In these findings, I heard echoes of the soberingly-named 2023 report Our Epidemic of Loneliness and Isolation by former US Surgeon General Dr. Vivek Murthy—the subject of a blog post I wrote back in May 2023. Murthy’s report defined loneliness as “a subjective distressing experience that results from perceived isolation or inadequate meaningful connections, where inadequate refers to the discrepancy or unmet need between an individual’s preferred and actual experience.” Murthy called on Americans to “build a movement to mend the social fabric of our nation,” and he cited human connectedness as the key to that movement. 

At its most basic level, the Child Mind report confirms that, for adolescents, our national progress with this movement has been a mixed bag. But the report merits a deeper dive. The study takes a more expansive view of connectedness, defining it across five domains (family, peer, school, self, and digital) and attempting to consider the interplay between the domains. And this leads to some lower-profile insights that are nevertheless interesting to me as an educator and parent of adolescents.

Self-Connectedness is underappreciated. Of the five domains, “Self-Connectedness” receives the least attention in the report, and I suppose I can understand why. The family, peer, and school domains address social development and interpersonal relationships, which are hugely critical in adolescence, and digital connectedness feels especially timely. On the other hand, the concept of being connected to and accepting of “one’s own inner experience” and acting “in alignment with the inner self” seems like a lot to ask of teens, like we’re asking them to do something that goes against their true nature. But it’s important not to overlook this aspect of connectedness, because being self-aware and having a degree of agency to act on one’s own behalf builds confidence and resilience. It’s why we frequently ask students to reflect on who they are as learners, why we have Student-Led Conferences, and why the first of our three Learner Practices is Ownership Over Learning. 

In my role as Outplacement Coordinator, I am fond of noting that we currently have over 100 alumni attending about 25 high schools in the DMV and beyond, schools that run the gamut from small, progressive institutions to large, traditional settings. The reason for the variety is clear in my mind: by the time students reach 8th Grade, they have a strong sense of who they are, what they need as learners, and how to advocate for what they need. And that’s in no small part due to our approach, which is rooted in inquiry and self-reflection. The confidence of highly self-connected students was on display in our recent High School Alumni Forum, when one of our graduates dryly reflected on how the high school open house tours they attended featured gushing tour guides and no small amount of self-promotion. She had the presence of mind to realize, “they can’t all be the best, right?” and encouraged 8th Graders to talk to lots of people and ask specific questions to find out why a school is a good fit for them, regardless of name recognition. Another alum described the process as less about collecting facts and more about recognizing a feeling—after her shadow day at the high school where she would eventually enroll, she reported coming home “almost giddy...I just knew that was the place.” Regardless of the factors that drive their decision-making, our students know themselves, understand the importance of finding a place that speaks to them as individuals, and are empowered to act accordingly. That’s self-connectedness, and it lays the foundation for greater connectedness with others.

Digital Connectedness is a nuanced topic. Anything related to our digital lives, and especially the digital lives of children, is a hot-button issue. It has been this way for decades, but it seems even more intense with the proliferation of AI in seemingly all aspects of daily life. In this climate, it’s easy to fall back on simplistic statements: “AI is here to stay, so we have to use it.” “Screen time is bad for kids.” “What we need is to put down our phones and talk to each other.” I appreciate that the Child Mind report takes a more nuanced approach. While some of the most widely-held beliefs, such as the human desire for in-person connection and the connection between excessive scrolling and poor mental health, were present in the results, the study also found that digital connectedness was less correlated with prevalence of loneliness, anxiety, and depression than other forms of connectedness. Put another way, students who were more digitally connected were not necessarily happier, less anxious, and in better shape socially, but neither were they more anxious and in worse shape socially. Assuming students are not spending an excessive amount of time online each day (the report cited four hours!), it seems that the quality of the screen time and the nature of the interactions are the key determinants. The study also found that digital connectedness has less of a “buffering effect” than other domains. In other words, having online friendships and online conversations does not by itself compensate for lack of connectedness in other domains.

Discrepancy across domains merits attention. It is logical that students who feel low levels of connectedness would be at high risk for loneliness, anxiety, and depression. However, the study includes a more interesting takeaway: students who had larger discrepancies in their scores across domains were at even greater risk, regardless of their overall level of connectedness. To take one example: strong family connectedness, a well-developed sense of self, and a healthy digital life may not be enough to compensate for an intense feeling of disconnection from peers. In some ways, this seems to contradict the idea that success in one domain can be a buffer against challenges in another—for instance, that strong family ties can sustain students through challenges with peers, or that strong peer connections can help students cope with an unhappy school life. And to some extent, the buffering effect is real. But as Upper Grades Counselor Zoë Tron notes, discrepancy in scores across domains suggests what she calls “an overall imbalance of connectedness” that is caused by “major gaps” and “can lead to poorer outcomes.” The solution is not to ignore gaps and throw ourselves into strengthening strengths. Instead, she says “identifying where the gaps exist and then tailoring support to those domains is necessary in creating balance and overall satisfaction in connectedness.” For me, this is yet another reason why it is so important to cultivate strong home-school partnerships. When the lines of communication are open and a foundation of trust exists, staff and families can respond to concerns about connectedness in a coordinated and productive way, sharing pertinent insights and gaining a fuller understanding of the student’s needs that benefits everyone.

The Child Mind report makes a number of recommendations, including “use schools as a key setting for prevention,” since “schools are one of the few...environments that reach most teens.” We take this call to action seriously. Through our Advisory program, affinity groups, Buddy program, and clubs, as well as our overall approach to daily classroom learning, we strive to create a place characterized by the qualities identified in the survey as important for belonging:

  • Feeling understood
  • Emotional safety
  • Trust
  • Supportive relationships
  • Connecting through shared meaning and purpose  

Despite the sobering facts, the Child Mind report ultimately offers a hopeful perspective: we have the ability to do something about loneliness. To quote Zoë once more: “It is clear from this study that helping teens (and preteens) with connectedness is not passive but instead active work for parents and school staff, and can lead to positive outcomes.”

More Division Edition articles:

By Tom Sellevaag, Upper Grades Head

I’ve written before in this space about spring as an exciting and rewarding time in the life of our School—when we see our efforts come to fruition, celebrate successes of the past year, and get to make plans for next year. 

Keep Reading

Leslie's Blog

Director of Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging

Discover how we foster a sense of belonging.

Read Here

Jason's Blog

Head of School

Learn more about our community and culture.

Read Here

Dive into Our Programs

Early Childhood, Elementary, and Upper Grades